Best Pacifiers for Breastfed Babies

Best Pacifiers for Breastfed Babies – Buyer’s Guide & Reviews

MAM Night Orthodontic Pacifier, Boy, 0-6 Plus Months, 2-Count

If you are looking for the best pacifier for your newborn baby, we prepared a list of favorites that might help you pick the right one. These pacifiers are BPA-free, hygienic, easy to clean, and will become your new best friend when your child is having trouble sleeping. Read all about the best pacifiers for breastfeed babies available in the market right now.

Baby pacifiers can be lifesavers for most moms. 

These small products can help your baby fall asleep faster and feel more comfortable. Some pacifiers are great at imitating the nipple, so your baby is going to feel like he or she is being breastfed.

Unfortunately, there are some pacifiers that are suitable for a breastfed baby as they might interfere with breastfeeding. For this reason, we have carefully selected the five highly recommended pacifiers for breastfed babies to help you save time shopping and find the best deal for you and your little angel.

Top 5 Best Pacifiers for Breastfed Babies

Best Pacifiers for Breastfed Babies

1. Philips Avent SCF190/01 Soothie

Philips Avent SCF190/01 Soothie 0-3mth Green/Green, 2pk

The Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier is one of the best pacifiers among many choices for mothers of breastfed babies.

  • The Soothie model has a special design that lets the gum and jaw of your newborn develop.
  • It is entirely made of silicone and it is BPA-free. Also, in order for the baby to accept the pacifier, this model is free of flavors and odors.
  • Another great thing about the Avent Soothie pacifier is that it is dishwasher-safe.

Since it comes in a solid piece, you don’t have to worry about trapped moisture, bacteria, or choking hazard. The snap-on cap is great for hygienic storage. This also helps keep it clean since babies tend to drop things when they are smaller.

2. MAM Night Orthodontic Pacifier

MAM Night Orthodontic Pacifier, Boy, 0-6 Plus Months, 2-Count

This best pacifiers for breastfed babies is another great option for your baby. It is the biggest version of the orthodontic pacifier series, which means that it is designed for babies 6 months of age.

  • MAM pacifiers support gum development and it doesn’t interfere with the growth of the teeth.
  • Also, the nipple of the pacifier is made out of soft silicone with the anti-slip feature.

You’ll be thrilled to know that the night orthodontic pacifier glows in the dark, which makes it easier to spot at night. It doesn’t have any odors or flavors, which makes it easier for breastfeed babies to accept. Like most pacifiers, this is a BPA-free product.

3. NUK Newborn 100% Silicone Orthodontic Pacifier

NUK Newborn 100% Silicone Boy Orthodontic Pacifier in Blue and Green, 0-3 Months, 2 count

Another amazing pacifier meant for breastfed infants is one developed by NUK. This model also promotes healthy oral development along with correct teeth alignment.

One of the best things about this pacifier is that it is 100% silicone, so you know it’s safe for babies with latex allergies. 

It has a one-piece construction which is more hygienic and it follows the guidelines of the American Academy of Pediatrics. This pacifier has a cut-off under the nose of the baby in order to allow the baby to breathe without any problems and, since it’s made for infants 0-3 months old, its smallish design allows it to fit in your baby’s tiny mouth.

4. The First Years GumDrop Newborn Pacifier

The First Years GumDrop Newborn Pacifier

One good thing about this type of pacifier is the fact that it is meant to stay away from the baby’s nose, allowing him to breathe more easily.

  • Its one-piece design makes it is easy to sterilize and ideal for preventing any choking hazards.
  • This pacifier leaves enough space for your baby to breathe without problems.
  • The GumDrop pacifier is Latex-free, Phthalate-free, and BPA-free, so it’s safe for baby’s health.

Like the other pacifiers, this one is also made out of silicone, which means no parent would ever worry about breaking into pieces after using it for some time.

This pacifier doesn’t trigger any nipple confusions issues for small babies. It is easily accepted by breastfed babies.

This one-piece pacifier is designed for babies between 0 and 3 months old. Though, as your baby grows, you can find this specific pacifier in bigger sizes that are more appropriate for older babies.

One of the best things about this pacifier is the fact that it is compatible with many pacifier attachments. Another wonderful thing about the First Years GumDrop Newborn Pacifier is its affordability, so you don’t spend on anything that your tiny bundle of joy will eventually outgrow in no time.

5. Tommee Tippee Closer to Nature Fun Pacifier

	 Tommee Tippee Closer to Nature Fun Pacifier, 6-18 Months, 2 Count (Colors will vary)

The last but not least product on our top 5 is the Fun pacifier designed by Tommee Tippee. This pacifier is best for 6-18 month-old babies. There are smaller models for babies younger than 6 months.

  • It has a symmetrical orthodontic shape that promotes better oral development.
  • The nipple of the pacifier resembles that of the baby bottles so it can be accepted by bottle-fed babies.

All of the pacifier designed by this brand have the same nipple format so you can switch from one a pacifier to another without causing confusion to your baby.

Another great thing about this pacifier is its attractive designs. It comes in various colors and patterns that are going to make you smile every time your baby uses the product.

Advantages of Pacifiers

Best Pacifiers for Breastfed Babies

Studies show  that pacifiers could potentially save your child’s life, apart from it being a better alternative to thumb sucking. 

Babies using pacifiers are less likely to die from sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) while they are sleeping. One other advantage would be the fact that they are good with soothing and distracting during vaccinations.

Pacifiers help babies fall asleep faster and are a good way to sooth the baby while flying. So, if you are planning a vacation with your breastfed baby, make sure that to take one pacifier with you.

Disadvantages of Pacifiers

If a baby continues to use a pacifier for more than two years, there’s a chance that he/she will develop the so-called pacifier teeth (tooth dental complications resulted from using the pacifier for too long).

For breastfed infants, switching from a pacifier to mother’s breast may also cause what people call nipple confusion. There is also a chance that pacifiers won’t work effectively in soothing babies, especially those that are breastfed. While there are newborn pacifiers for breastfed babies, they don’t offer the same soothing warmth babies find when they are snuggled close to their mother’s breast. On the contrary, once the baby gets used to the pacifier, it might be hard for parents to make them give up on it.

Are Pacifiers Safe for Newborn Babies

Generally, pacifiers are safe even for newborn infants. The only thing you need to worry about as a parent is a danger of choking since a newborn has a smaller mouth compared to older babies, so make sure you get one of those small pacifiers for breastfed babies.

Types of Pacifiers

The market is flooded with all sorts of pacifiers for babies of all ages. They come in several sizes, shapes, and even function. Here are some of the most popular among parents and babies.

Orthodontic Baby Pacifiers

These stylish binkies are not only meant to soothe your baby; they are also designed to promote healthy teeth and gum development.

Teething Pacifiers

Commonly made of silicone, these one-piece pacifiers are larger than your typical binkies and are popular among teething babies.

One-piece Pacifiers

As the name implies, these pacifiers come in one solid piece and are usually made of silicone. They are preferred by most moms because they are less likely to cause choking among infants, but most especially among older babies who are capable of manipulating objects and tearing things apart. One-piece soothers are definitely one of the best pacifiers good for breastfed babies.

Multiple-piece pacifiers

These are the most common type of pacifiers you see in the market. They are usually made of a nipple, a nipple guard and a ring manufactured separately and have been put together to make one single product.

How to Choose the Best Pacifiers for Baby

The sad truth is, you can’t. Ultimately, it’s baby who gets to decide which pacifier he or she will choose. The best you can do is purchase two or three types that are the right size for baby’s age and see what gets accepted.

What to Consider: Buying Pacifiers for Newborn

Remember that there is no guarantee your baby will accept the first pacifier you offer, so make sure the one you’re getting is offered at a reasonably good price. Additionally, opt for one-piece and dishwasher safe product to ensure safety.

Final Review of the Best Pacifiers for Breastfed Babies

The best pacifiers for breastfed babies can be life-savers when babies are fussy or when they can’t fall asleep. These are the top 5 choices when it comes to pacifiers designed especially for breastfed babies.


As you can see, all the newborn pacifiers for breastfed babies featured here are BPA-free. They all promote healthy oral development, without interrupting the teething process. They come in various colors and patterns so you can choose the one that’s best for your child.


Also, all of the pacifiers mentioned above are hygienic and they follow guidelines in order to offer only the best for your baby. Now you just have to pick the perfect one.

Related Buyer’s guides and MomTrustedChoice Lists:

About the Author Barbara Davis

Hey there, I'm Barbara Davis, founder and editor in chief here at Mom Trusted Choice. Motherhood is hard work, but it’s also full of surprises and laughter. With every passing month, the joy and excitement keep getting bigger and bigger. The journey never ends, and that’s what I love about it the most and want to share with all of you.

follow me on:

Leave a Comment:

Popular posts

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This